Cracked Screen vs. Cracked Screen Protector: How to Tell and What to Do

When dealing with a damaged phone display, you may wonder: cracked screen vs. cracked screen protector—how can you tell the difference? Many users panic at the sight of cracks, but in some cases, the damage is only to the screen protector, not the actual phone screen. Identifying the issue correctly is crucial because it determines whether you need a simple protector replacement or a full screen repair.

This guide will help you quickly diagnose whether your phone screen is cracked or if it's just your screen protector. Understanding the difference can save you time, money, and unnecessary stress, ensuring you take the right steps toward fixing the issue.

How to Tell If Your Phone Has a Cracked Screen or Just a Cracked Screen Protector

If you notice cracks on your phone, follow these simple tests to determine if the damage is limited to your screen protector or if your actual phone screen is affected.

1. Check for Raised Edges

Run your fingers across the surface of your phone. If you feel raised or rough edges, it’s likely that your screen protector is cracked, not the actual screen. Tempered glass protectors tend to fracture upon impact to absorb shock, preventing damage to your phone screen underneath.

However, if the surface feels smooth despite visible cracks, the damage may extend beyond the protector, or your phone screen itself could be affected.

2. Run a Fingernail Over the Crack

Gently slide your fingernail over the cracked area:

• If the crack feels shallow and doesn’t disrupt the smoothness of the screen, it’s likely just the protector.
• If your nail catches on the crack or it feels deep and uneven, the actual phone screen is probably damaged.

This is one of the quickest ways to identify the extent of the damage without removing your protector.

3. Turn Off the Screen and Inspect the Crack

Turn off your phone’s screen and observe the cracks in good lighting.

• If the cracks disappear or are difficult to see, the screen protector is likely the only thing damaged.
• If the cracks remain visible even when the screen is off, your actual phone screen is likely cracked.

A cracked phone screen will have internal fractures that don’t disappear, whereas a cracked protector often reflects light differently, making it appear less visible when the screen is off.

4. Check for Display Issues

If your phone’s display is acting strange, the problem goes beyond just a cracked protector. Look for these signs:

• Touchscreen Issues – If your phone screen isn’t responding properly or registers touches in the wrong places, your actual screen may be damaged.
• Dead Pixels or Black Spots – If you see black spots, lines, or flickering colors, the phone’s LCD or OLED display is affected.
• Discoloration or Screen Bleeding – Any strange color shifts or dark blotches indicate internal screen damage.

If any of these issues appear, the phone itself needs repair, even if the protector is also cracked.

5. Peel Off the Screen Protector

If you’re still unsure, carefully remove the screen protector and check the phone’s screen underneath.

• If your phone screen looks intact and smooth after removal, the cracks were only on the protector, and you simply need a new one.
• If cracks remain or the screen is visibly damaged underneath, your phone screen itself is cracked and will need professional repair.
• Important: If the screen protector is severely shattered, use caution while removing it to avoid injury from glass shards.

What to Do If You Have a Cracked Screen Protector

A cracked screen protector has done its job by absorbing the impact and preventing damage to your phone screen. However, a broken protector should be replaced immediately to ensure your phone remains protected. Follow these steps to handle a cracked screen protector properly.

Replace It Immediately

Screen protectors are designed to take the hit instead of your phone screen. If your protector is cracked, it has lost its ability to absorb future impacts. Leaving a damaged protector on can lead to:

• Reduced touchscreen responsiveness
• Increased risk of screen damage in case of another drop
• Sharp edges or glass splinters that could cause injury

To keep your phone fully protected, replace the cracked screen protector as soon as possible.

Look for Signs of Additional Damage

Before applying a new protector, inspect your phone screen for any hidden damage:

• Turn off your phone and check for any cracks that may have gone through to the actual screen.
• Check for touchscreen issues, discoloration, or dead pixels—these indicate screen damage, not just a cracked protector.
• Use a flashlight to inspect for any faint cracks that might not be easily visible.

If the screen itself looks intact, you can proceed with replacing the screen protector. If you notice screen damage, your phone may need professional repair.

Choose the Right Replacement

When selecting a new screen protector, choose one that provides the best protection for your needs.

Tempered Glass Screen Protector (Recommended)

• Best protection against drops and impact.
• Absorbs shock, reducing the risk of screen cracks.
• Offers a smooth, glass-like feel for touchscreen accuracy.
• More durable and lasts longer than plastic films.

Plastic Film Screen Protector (Budget Option)

• Cheaper alternative but provides minimal drop protection.
• Helps prevent scratches but won’t absorb strong impacts.
• Works well for preventing fingerprints and light wear.

For maximum protection, a tempered glass screen protector is the best choice, especially for phones prone to drops.

What to Do If Your Phone Screen Is Cracked

A cracked phone screen needs immediate attention to prevent further damage. Follow these steps to protect your device:

Assess the Severity of the Crack

• Small hairline cracks may not affect functionality but can spread over time. A screen protector can help minimize further damage.
• Major cracks or shattered screens require immediate repair. The touchscreen may be unresponsive, and glass shards pose a safety risk.

Backup Your Data

Cracks can worsen unexpectedly, so back up your data immediately using cloud storage (Google Drive, iCloud) or a computer connection in case the screen stops working.

Avoid Using the Phone If Glass Is Loose

• Loose glass can cause injuries and allow dust or moisture inside.
• Handle the phone carefully and avoid pressing on the damaged area.

Get Professional Repair

A cracked screen won’t fix itself. Pull Up Phone Repair offers fast phone screen repair in Baltimore, on-location repairs in under 15 minutes, with high-quality replacement screens and a limited lifetime warranty.

How to Prevent Cracks in the Future

Avoiding cracks in your screen starts with proper protection and mindful handling. Here are three simple ways to keep your phone safe:

Use a High-Quality Screen Protector

A tempered glass screen protector absorbs impact and prevents your screen from cracking. If it breaks, replacing it is much cheaper than repairing your phone screen.

Invest in a Shockproof Phone Case

A durable case with raised edges protects your phone from accidental drops. Look for military-grade protection or brands known for durability.

Be Mindful of Where You Place Your Phone

Keep your phone away from table edges, tight pockets with keys, and high surfaces where it’s likely to fall. A little caution goes a long way in preventing damage.

Why Choose Pull Up Phone Repair for Screen Repairs?

Fast and Affordable On-Demand Repairs

We come to your location and fix your phone in under 15 minutes—no waiting in line or sending your device away.

High-Quality Replacement Screens

We use OEM-grade parts to ensure durability, responsiveness, and a perfect fit for your phone.

Limited Lifetime Warranty

Every repair comes with a limited lifetime warranty, so you get peace of mind with your screen replacement.

Serving New Jersey, New York, Philadelphia, and Maryland

Our mobile repair service covers multiple locations, providing expert, convenient service right at your doorstep.

Identify and Fix Your Cracked Screen or Screen Protector Today

Knowing the difference between a cracked screen vs. cracked screen protector helps you decide the best course of action. Replace your screen protector if it’s damaged, and if your screen is cracked, get it repaired quickly to prevent further issues. Book a phone repair with us today! 

‍